Lee County Island Living

Pine Island Homes for Sale in St. James City and Bokeelia, FL

The largest island on Florida's Gulf Coast, with Old Florida boating towns and no beaches or high-rises.

Short answer: Pine Island is the largest island on Florida's Gulf Coast, in Lee County west of Cape Coral. Its towns include St. James City on the south end, Bokeelia and Pineland on the north end, and Pine Island Center in the middle, connected by the 16-mile Stringfellow Road.

Boating and Fishing

The island is surrounded by Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor and Matlacha Pass, so many homes sit on canals with quick boat access to the sound, the outer islands and the Gulf. Housing ranges from older bungalows and stilt homes to remodeled waterfront homes.

Before You Buy

Hurricane Ian hit the island in 2022, and parts of it are still rebuilding. Check each property's flood zone, elevation, storm history and canal depth before you buy.

Pine Island Market Snapshot

Active listings as of November 21, 2026, and closed sales from November 21, 2025 to November 21, 2026, from Southwest Florida MLS residential data.

Figures cover residential listings in the MLS Pine Island North and South areas, which include St. James City and Bokeelia.

Active listings180
Active price range$90K – $4.80M
Median list price$452K
Sales, last 12 months268
Median sale price$406K
Sale price range$50K – $1.75M
Median days on market (sold)80
Median price per sq ft (sold)$295

Source: Southwest Florida MLS. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Neighborhoods in Pine Island

The neighborhoods with the most recent activity include Cherry Estates, Pine Island Cove, Pine Island, St. James City, Gulfhaven and Knights Bokeelia Isle.

More Communities

See Matlacha or read the waterfront guide. Browse other Cape Coral communities.

Frequently Asked Questions

What towns are on Pine Island?

St. James City, Bokeelia, Pineland and Pine Island Center. Matlacha sits on its own small island next to it.

Does Pine Island have beaches?

Pine Island is ringed by mangroves rather than beaches. Boaters reach the outer island beaches by water.

What do homes on Pine Island cost?

Over the last 12 months, 268 homes sold on Pine Island at a median price of $406K, ranging from $50K to $1.75M. There were 180 active listings, with a median list price of $452K.

Thinking About Pine Island?

Tell us what matters most, and we will send current Pine Island listings and recent sales.