Fort Myers Beach Boating Island

San Carlos Island Homes for Sale in Fort Myers Beach, FL

The working waterfront at the foot of the Fort Myers Beach bridge, with marinas, shrimp docks and Gulf-access homes.

Short answer: San Carlos Island is a small island just north of Fort Myers Beach, on San Carlos Boulevard at the foot of the Matanzas Pass bridge. It is home to marinas, the shrimp fleet, charter boats and the Key West Express, and it sits in unincorporated Lee County rather than the Town of Fort Myers Beach.

Homes

Housing ranges from manufactured-home and RV condos to waterfront single-family homes. The western edge, in San Carlos on the Gulf, has large elevated homes on deep water with no bridges to Estero Bay and the Gulf.

Lifestyle

Residents can walk, bike or take a golf cart over the bridge to the beach, while avoiding much of the island traffic.

San Carlos Island Market Data

San Carlos Island spans many small subdivisions and condos, and the MLS files only a handful of single-family sales there each year, so we are not publishing a single snapshot. Ask us for current listings by street or building.

More Communities

See lake vs. Gulf access communities. Nearby: Matanzas Pass and Times Square. Browse other Fort Myers Beach communities.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is San Carlos Island part of the Town of Fort Myers Beach?

No. It is unincorporated Lee County with a Fort Myers Beach address.

Does San Carlos Island have Gulf access?

Yes. Many waterfront lots have deep water with no bridges to Estero Bay and the Gulf.

Thinking About San Carlos Island?

Tell us what matters most, and we will send current San Carlos Island listings and recent sales.