Sarasota County Barrier Island

Casey Key Homes for Sale in Nokomis, FL

A private, nine-mile barrier island of Gulf-to-bay estates in Osprey and Nokomis.

Short answer: Casey Key is a nine-mile-long residential barrier island between the Gulf and Blackburn Bay, reached by a historic 1920s swing bridge from Osprey and by a bridge in Nokomis. It has about 400 parcels, many of them Gulf-to-bay estates, and is known for its privacy.

Lifestyle

The public Nokomis Beach is at the island's south end, and most of the island is quiet residential land.

This community is outside the Southwest Florida MLS coverage area, so we do not publish a market snapshot here. Contact us for current listings and recent sales.

Casey Key Market Snapshot

Active listings as of November 21, 2026, and closed sales from November 21, 2025 to November 21, 2026, from Stellar MLS residential data.

Active listings15
Active price range$485K – $12.65M
Median list price$5.75M
Sales, last 12 months17
Median sale price$3M
Sale price range$525K – $9M
Median days on market (sold)143
Median price per sq ft (sold)$826

Source: Stellar MLS. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

More Communities

Read the waterfront guide or compare Gulf-access homes with no bridges. Browse other Sarasota to Tampa Bay communities.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is Casey Key?

About nine miles.

How many homes are on Casey Key?

About 400 parcels.

Thinking About Casey Key?

Tell us what matters most, and we will send current Casey Key listings and recent sales.